Stoic Rebuttal MTG Card


Stoic Rebuttal provides control via card advantage, allowing strategic counterplays at instant speed. Affinity for artifacts enhances mana efficiency but requires careful planning around metalcraft. Despite mana cost concerns, Stoic Rebuttal’s versatility makes it a worthy addition to many decks.
Card setsReleased in 3 setsSee all
Mana cost
Converted mana cost3
RarityCommon
TypeInstant
Abilities Metalcraft

Text of card

Metalcraft — Stoic Rebuttal costs less to cast if you control three or more artifacts. Counter target spell.

Obsessed with the pursuit of knowledge above all else, vedalken can appear to be cold and emotionless.


Cards like Stoic Rebuttal

Stoic Rebuttal springs into the realm of Magic: The Gathering as a compelling counter spell, drawing parallels with iconic pieces like Cancel. Both Stoic Rebuttal and Cancel allow a player to counter any spell at the cost of three mana. The distinguishing feature of Stoic Rebuttal is its Metalcraft ability, which reduces the spell’s cost under specific conditions — having three or more artifacts on the battlefield resulting in a more cost-efficient play.

Manaleak is another card with a similar function, offering a disruptive counterplay at a lower cost. It provides a more aggressive early game play, though it becomes less effective as the opponent’s mana pool grows. Conversely, Stoic Rebuttal maintains its relevance throughout the game, provided the artifact condition is met. Deprive is a formidable competitor as well, with a unique cost of returning a land to its owner’s hand instead of a higher mana payment, focusing on flexibility over raw efficiency.

Assessing the spectrum of counter spells in Magic: The Gathering, Stoic Rebuttal presents a robust option for decks that can reliably meet its Metalcraft condition, balancing cost-efficiency with broad countering power.

Cancel - MTG Card versions
Deprive - MTG Card versions
Cancel - MTG Card versions
Deprive - MTG Card versions

Cards similar to Stoic Rebuttal by color, type and mana cost

Mana Short - MTG Card versions
Psionic Blast - MTG Card versions
Capsize - MTG Card versions
Forbid - MTG Card versions
Frantic Search - MTG Card versions
Exclude - MTG Card versions
Crystal Spray - MTG Card versions
Hibernation - MTG Card versions
Circular Logic - MTG Card versions
Keep Watch - MTG Card versions
Archmage's Charm - MTG Card versions
Commander's Insight - MTG Card versions
Ixidor's Will - MTG Card versions
Catalog - MTG Card versions
Vex - MTG Card versions
Thirst for Knowledge - MTG Card versions
Murmurs from Beyond - MTG Card versions
Venser's Diffusion - MTG Card versions
Dream Fracture - MTG Card versions
Oona's Grace - MTG Card versions
Mana Short - MTG Card versions
Psionic Blast - MTG Card versions
Capsize - MTG Card versions
Forbid - MTG Card versions
Frantic Search - MTG Card versions
Exclude - MTG Card versions
Crystal Spray - MTG Card versions
Hibernation - MTG Card versions
Circular Logic - MTG Card versions
Keep Watch - MTG Card versions
Archmage's Charm - MTG Card versions
Commander's Insight - MTG Card versions
Ixidor's Will - MTG Card versions
Catalog - MTG Card versions
Vex - MTG Card versions
Thirst for Knowledge - MTG Card versions
Murmurs from Beyond - MTG Card versions
Venser's Diffusion - MTG Card versions
Dream Fracture - MTG Card versions
Oona's Grace - MTG Card versions

Card Pros

Card Advantage: Stoic Rebuttal offers a direct avenue to maintaining control of the board by countering key spells your opponent casts, ensuring you keep the upper hand in card interaction and strategy.

Resource Acceleration: With its affinity for artifacts, Stoic Rebuttal can potentially cost less to cast, effectively speeding up your mana use and allowing you to allocate resources to other spells and abilities more rapidly.

Instant Speed: As an instant, Stoic Rebuttal can be deployed at the most opportune moment, often during an opponent’s turn, providing flexibility and surprise within your strategic plays, while also maximizing the potential for favorable exchanges on the stack.


Card Cons

Discard Requirement: Although Stoic Rebuttal does not directly require you to discard a card, it does necessitate having metalcraft to reduce its mana cost, which means ensuring you have three artifacts on the field. This stipulation could force you to commit more cards to the board than desirable, making you vulnerable to mass removal and potentially leaving you with fewer cards in hand as you plan out your artifact deployment.

Specific Mana Cost: Stoic Rebuttal’s mana cost includes two blue mana, making it a card that generally fits best in mono-blue or blue-heavy decks. This particular mana requirement can restrict the card’s utility in multicolored decks that might not always have the necessary blue mana sources available when needed.

Comparatively High Mana Cost: With a mana cost of one colorless and two blue mana—three in total, or two if you have the metalcraft ability active—Stoic Rebuttal is at a mana disadvantage compared to its counterpart, Counterspell, which performs the same function for less mana. Even with metalcraft, the need to maintain three artifacts to gain the cost reduction can be cumbersome, potentially affecting your deck-building decisions and how you play your cards during a match.


Reasons to Include Stoic Rebuttal in Your Collection

Versatility: Stoic Rebuttal serves as a core countermeasure in blue-centric or artifact heavy decks, offering an efficient way to handle threats by countering any spell when the conditions are met. Its flexibility comes from having Metalcraft, potentially reducing its cost when you control three or more artifacts.

Combo Potential: For decks that utilize artifacts, this card synergizes well with strategies that revolve around artifacts. Players can creatively build their board state to enable the Metalcraft bonus while keeping mana open for a timely counter.

Meta-Relevance: Given that control decks remain a fixture in various metagames, having cost-effective counters like Stoic Rebuttal can swing games in your favor. It accords with decks aimed at disrupting opponents’ plans while progressing their board state with artifacts.


How to beat Stoic Rebuttal

Stoic Rebuttal has cemented its place as a trusted counterspell in blue-aligned MTG decks. Its strength lies in the Metalcraft ability, reducing its mana cost when you control three or more artifacts. To effectively counter this card, the key is in timing and resource management. Depleting the blue mage’s mana before they amass three artifacts can make Stoic Rebuttal harder to cast, forcing it to function as a pricier Cancel.

Threading through a web of counterspells requires threats that can either slip under the radar or demand multiple answers. Playing low-cost spells can draw out Stoic Rebuttal early, leaving the path clearer for your heavy-hitters. Alternatively, baiting out the Rebuttal with a spell you can afford to lose can leave your opponent vulnerable. Additionally, instant-speed spells can be played during the opponent’s turn, pressuring their mana and complicating their calculations for holding up Stoic Rebuttal. Lastly, consider including cards that can’t be countered or give your spells uncounterable status, ensuring your key plays land on the battlefield regardless of your opponent’s defenses.

Anticipating and reacting to a potential Stoic Rebuttal, with strategic deployment of threats and non-counterable spells, can drastically reduce its impact on your game plan, allowing you to maintain tempo and pressure in a match.


BurnMana Recommendations

The path to MTG mastery is both thrilling and nuanced, with every card selection making an impact on your deck’s performance. Stoic Rebuttal stands out as a powerful choice for players who favor control strategies and artifact play. Understanding this card’s strengths and limitations can be pivotal in any match. If you’re seeking to enhance your deck with effective counterspells and value versatility, Stoic Rebuttal might be the next addition to your collection. Dive deeper into strategic card analysis and deck optimization on our platform. Embrace the complexity of the game and refine your strategies with us. Discover the art of the perfect counter!


Where to buy

If you're looking to purchase Stoic Rebuttal MTG card by a specific set like Scars of Mirrodin and Duel Decks: Mirrodin Pure vs. New Phyrexia, there are several reliable options to consider. One of the primary sources is your local game store, where you can often find booster packs, individual cards, and preconstructed decks from current and some past sets. They often offer the added benefit of a community where you can trade with other players.

For a broader inventory, particularly of older sets, online marketplaces like TCGPlayer, Card Kingdom and Card Market offer extensive selections and allow you to search for cards from specific sets. Larger e-commerce platforms like eBay and Amazon also have listings from various sellers, which can be a good place to look for sealed product and rare finds.

Additionally, Magic’s official site often has a store locator and retailer lists for finding Wizards of the Coast licensed products. Remember to check for authenticity and the condition of the cards when purchasing, especially from individual sellers on larger marketplaces.

Below is a list of some store websites where you can buy the Stoic Rebuttal and other MTG cards:

TCGPlayerBUY NOW
BurnMana is an official partner of TCGPlayer
Continue exploring other sealed products in Amazon
See MTG Products

Printings

The Stoic Rebuttal Magic the Gathering card was released in 3 different sets between 2010-10-01 and 2015-05-22. Illustrated by Chris Rahn.

#ReleasedNameCodeSymbolNumberFrameLayoutBorderArtist
12010-10-01Scars of MirrodinSOM 462003NormalBlackChris Rahn
22011-05-14Duel Decks: Mirrodin Pure vs. New PhyrexiaTD2 342003NormalBlackChris Rahn
32015-05-22Modern Masters 2015MM2 592015NormalBlackChris Rahn

Legalities

Magic the Gathering formats where Stoic Rebuttal has restrictions

FormatLegality
CommanderLegal
LegacyLegal
PaupercommanderLegal
ModernLegal
OathbreakerLegal
PauperLegal
VintageLegal
DuelLegal
PredhLegal
PennyLegal

Rules and information

The reference guide for Magic: The Gathering Stoic Rebuttal card rulings provides official rulings, any errata issued, as well as a record of all the functional modifications that have occurred.

Date Text
2011-01-01 For the purpose of determining whether the cost reduction applies, the number of artifacts you control is checked as you cast Stoic Rebuttal, before your last chance to activate mana abilities to pay for it. For example, if you control three artifacts, you could determine that Stoic Rebuttal costs to cast, then sacrifice one of those artifacts to activate a mana ability.
2011-01-01 Stoic Rebuttal’s metalcraft ability functions while Stoic Rebuttal is on the stack.